Sunday, April 18, 2010

poof

that's the sound of me blowing a little air into the wind, where it will be carried off instantly as tiny particles, mingling with other tiny particles, more numerous even than there are harry potter fans. there won't be any proof of that poof, no record or memory, except for this.

sigh. i love the internet so very much, to borrow one of my daughter's current phrases. because, though less than polished, the things i write here are more than journal entries. obviously. if i were journaling, i would be writing in my padlocked diary [blog] that is TOTALLY PASSWORD PROTECTED. i write here because, even though i am pretty sure i've got a teeny, tiny readership, mostly made up of family members who are obligated to read, i still know i'm not just talking to myself. does anyone really write without hoping to be read? even my actual journal is intended to be read someday, after i am dead.

:: :: ::

i love Sunday nights. the girls are sleeping in their beds, i have Li-Young Lee's latest collection on my lap, and there are at least three hours before i absolutely have to shut 'er down. i can think. i can write down my thoughts. i can feel cool air coming in through the window. and i can forget about the messy house on the other side of my door {sufficient unto tomorrow is the evil of that. if you know whaddamean}.

:: :: ::

Li-Young, where was this book in 2002 when i was writing my master's thesis? my title was, "a witnessing to magnitude: poems of spirituality in form and free verse." and i struggled to find any in the contemporary canon. really struggled. since then harold bloom has written a whole book about it and it's suddenly a cool thing for poets to sincerely explore their religious roots. oh, well. i found that paper of mine recently and read a few excerpts. who is this person?, i wanted to know. i could go 50 pages through that thing without recalling a single sentence. it didn't teach me what i wanted to know.

this collection, on the other hand, is full of moments you find in poetry when you hear your own voice ringing in the words--only not your voice as you speak it to others, but your authentic voice: the one that can really only be expressed in this strange medium. poetry lovers, do you know what i mean? {are you out there?}

i find myself wanting to finish the sentences.

:: :: ::

from "Cuckoo Flower on the Witness Stand" by Li-Young Lee

When asked about my religious training, I answer,
"I seek my destiny in my origin."

Most of my life, I've answered politely
to questions put to me, speaking only when spoken to,

a sign of weakness
unbefitting of any free human being.

. .

Therefore, for the sake of free human beings everywhere,
and because no one asked, I now say:

:: :: ::

well, i have several things to say, but here is just one. this post is alternately titled, "in defense of public badness. also public goodness."*

THE IMPETUS
i've long followed the admonition that bad behavior, yea even the appearance thereof, sets a bad example for the youth and other impressionable folks. i know this to be true, as a member of the latter category. be careful what you smoke around me because, chances are, i will really want to smoke it too.

but i have been more helped than hurt by good people who are also bad. likewise by bad people who are also good. if you're a baddy of my acquaintance, consider this a thank-you note on cyber-stationery.

THE ARGUMENT
if someone tells you that stealing is bad and then you see a person steal, isn't it logical to connect the triangle {person=bad}? i reasoned this way as a child and probably still do, sometimes, although i know better. mostly we overcome deductions like this as we age and get wisdom. we realize that human motives are complicated and defy simple categorization. we desire grace for ourselves and extend it more willingly to others.

THE CONFESSION
and we want to kick the crap out of people who don't fess up to their own badness {hyprocrites! no grace for you! no soup, either!}.

THE ARGUMENT, WITH NUMBERS
that reaction is not super helpful. what is helpful: listening to lucinda williams. also, an exercise in observation. i observe that people i know and trust do things that i have been taught are bad-to-do. my deductions? (1) sometimes people fail. (2) not all things that i have been taught are bad-to-do are actually bad-to-do. do you hear what i am saying? not everything i was taught is true. accepted truths are not always true. i know. FRIGHTENING! RADICAL and DANGEROUS! believe me, i know. and i am now two steps closer to enlightenment, no joke.

LIKEWISE
sometimes people who are trying to do everything right are just people trying really hard to do right. if that's not okay with you, you'd better run and hide from me. because i am officially claiming that fundamental {excuse that word} right for all the goodies. keep it up, goodies. you are okay.

THE POINT
i am a little bit bad too, and i resolve to show it. not because it is cool, but because it is human and human is a good thing to be.

*can you tell i've been reading a little bit of michel de montaigne here and there? it makes me want to go around defending things, treatising and manifesto-ing. and don't be impressed. reading a few paragraphs does not a scholar make. but oh, i just found a cheerio in my bra. i so deserved this evening of solitude.

THE END

now, if you made it all the way to the end of this post, hi! leave a comment. i want to know how far my poof reached. for science.

16 of you said:

Shawn said...

It reached clear to American Canyon and fascinated me. And I will only "poof" back about a little of it, even though I thoroughly enjoyed all of it. I also am sitting here on a Sunday night all alone, after everyone else sleeps, enjoying my solitude. Mikey just fell asleep on my shoulder and I put him to bed in his mom's room. Sweetness. There is cool air coming in through the window of my room upstairs where I will sleep later after it cools down a bit. But for now, I'm just quietly taking in your words of wisdom and doing a little pondering of my own. Finally, at 10 pm, the day of rest becomes the day of rest.

And I like all them things you said.

Jessica said...

Be still my Arrested-Development-loving heart. You are awesome.

I am a little bit bad, too. Like today. I broke the Sabbath. Twice. (Yeah I know, after the first time, you've broken the Sabbath. No use in counting, right?) For caffeine! (Thrice?)

I really like you. And your writing.

Could you do a post on poetry for beginners? I'm a beginner, see, and I'm not sure where to begin.

dietcokegrrl said...

The more I get to know you--the more I really really like you.

It's nice to know that I'm not the only little bit bad one...someday we'll have to sit and swap stories. Or write a few new ones.

And Jessica--I, too, broke the Sabbath today. For caffeine as well. Lack of sleep and a Diet Coke addiction get me every time.

Megara said...

It is 7:16 on Monday morning. Both children are still sleeping, just saw Brian off to work, and I am going to take advantage of all this and head back to my cozy bed, but before that, I wanted to let you know that I read your post and that it made me think, but not too much yet, as my brain does not usually wake up until around 8:30 :)

Janae said...

It got to me!

Natalie said...

And to me. I love your thoughts on this matter and feel where you are coming from. I am finally to the point in my life where I really am ok with myself whether I am "bad" in the eyes of some,or "good" in the eyes of others. I am what I am.

I loved this post.

Sarah said...

I read it. And I think I got it. Just oh so tired. But I love you in all of your goodness and badness. And I miss you more than words.

richard dandelion said...

As a confirmed baddie with an especial penchant for poofing, I appreciate the outreach. We baddies need all the help we can get!

miss kitti said...

This so meshes with my newer philosophy of life. I do think mostly people are trying to do what's best or sometimes whatever will work.

I fully support you in being human and showing your badness. I've been working on that in my own corner of the world.

annie said...

I am finger typing on my phone. so this is all for now. I think I will digest and come back later and maybe say more. until then, I heart you more than glee. and that's sayin somethin.

also, sometimes I find chickpeas in my bra.

Jacks said...

I loved this. It is logical. And coming to this realization stinks. But in a nice, floral way. So my question: How do you deal with the understanding that you've been taught truths that really are not true?

How do you not allow anger and hurt that loving people spent years enforcing such truths?

Because I felt betrayed when I finally learned for myself that some things really do not matter in the eternal scheme of things.

And for one who has always needed to be a goodie in order to avoid overwhelming guilt, the inability to talk openly about such realizations drives me nuts. But I can't. And I won't ever be a true baddie. Because I don't want to beat myself up over it. And I'm a wimp. And sometimes it's easier to just be a wimp.

Sherry Carpet said...

i am now going to steal richard dandelion's format for answering comments because i think it is cool.

@shawn: i read your comment and felt a peace flow through me. it was like we were doing the same thing at the same time. how nice it was for me to feel connected that way.

@jessica: i knew you had to love AD; you just HAD TO. i am not at all surprised and it just further confirms your greatness to me. i like the idea of a poetry post and i will totally do that, if even one person is interested. oh, you are? okay, then.

@dietcokegrrl: well, i knew i liked you the first time i saw your blog handle. so i will give diet coke the credit for starting our friendship. you don't know how much i have needed a friend who is so simpatico! it's a rare thing.

@megan: bless your HEART for being up reading blogs before 8 AM. you're a girl after my own heart. i can just picture you there--are you wrapped in a blanked nursing a diet coke? no? just me, then.

@janae: hey, girl! coming our way anytime soon? don't your kids like disneyland, or what?

@natalie: thanks for your words, sister. i would like to reach that pinnacle of self-acceptance. working on it.

@sarah: isn't it sort of great, though painful, that you can just keep missing someone for what seems like forever? i would love to live closer to you and not go so many years between visits. i miss our library days.

@richard: baddies rule!

@misskitti: i have long suspected that we are twins, but that you got the great hair, so there's a tension between us. but we still think alike about many important things and it keeps us close. sigh. to be closer.

@annie: CHICKPEAS?! rock. on.

@jacks: i think it is inevitable that we reach this painful (and liberating) conclusion if we keep our eyes open and continue to walk forward. inevitable maybe because of the time we live in. i look at older people who have made it through life essentially unchanged in their beliefs and i wonder, HOW? there are lots of cultural reasons, but the biggest reason may be that we have access to so much information now. we can know things that were unknowable, or at least hard to find, for generations before ours. and once you know something, you can't unknow it very easily. and once you open that box, it doesn't want to stay closed.

i love you for being a goodie and i think you do it so gracefully. take comfort in knowing you're truly not the only one out there feeling hurt and angry, and know that a lot of people have come through this triumphant. i find the anger fades when you realize that everyone who taught you did so in good faith. you weren't lied to--just imperfectly taught. We'll teach our children imperfectly too, and we'll hope and pray for them to have it just a little easier than we did.

richard dandelion said...

@SC: welcome to the twitterverse. That's tweetgrammar right there. Wish I could claim it. Oh wait, no I don't.

@SC & jacks (are you who I think you are?): this tension--that the folks you trust the most are teaching/have taught untruths for truths though doing so without lying--is, I think, unavoidably difficult to deal with. (<--untruth?)

Processing pain inflicted without malice is far harder than processing it when there's a clearly intention-driven enemy upon whom to visit blame.

annie said...

@sc - i really love everything about this post. and i wish i were brave enough to post responses for all the world to read, but i am not. so i will continue thinking my little thoughts and reading yours and saying, amen, sista.

@sc and rd - that all rings very true to me

Nicea said...

I read this post a couple of nights ago, too late to digest it all, but wanting to. What (among other things) rings true to me presently is your comment back @jacks: i look at older people who have made it through life essentially unchanged in their beliefs and i wonder, HOW? there are lots of cultural reasons, but the biggest reason may be that we have access to so much information now. we can know things that were unknowable, or at least hard to find, for generations before ours. and once you know something, you can't unknow it very easily. and once you open that box, it doesn't want to stay closed.

I think my mother, an older older person has managed to make it through her life with her beliefs unchanged. I, as just an older (in the singular) person, have changed some of my beliefs, but not without a great deal of self-questioning and doubt about my conclusions. Because it really is as hard to undo the old knowledge for the new as it is to go back to the old truths once you've learned the new. Change is hard. Especially in the pursuit of truth. And I'm like Natalie now: okay with who I am in all my mix of badness and goodness. Badder some days. Gooder others.

Lovely post. And lovely comments from everyone.

abbyjane said...

i made it to the end. phew! i think i got my exercise for the week.

i love you. and am bad sometimes. and i feel guilty about that until i read a post from you, and feel human again. and good too, which is even better than human.

happy mother's day!